Seau Family Suit Against NFL Rips ‘False Myth’ That Collisions Are Heroic

San Diego Superior Court makes public 60-page complaint two days after filing made world news.

Updated at 4:35 p.m. Jan. 25, 2013

Junior Seau’s suicide in May 2012 was a “direct and proximate result of having suffered multiple past traumatic brain injuries while playing professional football for the NFL from 1990-2009,” says his family’s lawsuit made public Friday for the first time.

Filed in San Diego Superior Court on Wednesday but not “imaged”—or posted online—until Friday morning,  the 60-page complaint is a devastating indictment of the National Football League.

It cites in detail the history of brain injuries suffered by players and alleges the NFL failed to act to prevent them.

“Part of the NFL Defendants’ strategy to promote NFL football is to glorify the brutality and ferocity of NFL football,” says the complaint on behalf of the family of the former Chargers linebacker and Oceanside resident.

The suit says the NFL lauds and mythologizes “the most brutal and ferocious players and collisions, [while] simultaneously propagating the fraudulent representation that ‘getting your bell rung,’ ‘being dinged’ and putting big hits on others is a badge of courage which does not seriously threaten one’s health.”

As a result of this strategy, the NFL propagated the “false myth” that collisions of all kinds, including brutal and ferocious collisions—“many of which lead to short-term and long-term neurological damage to players—are an acceptable, desired and natural consequence of the game, and a measure of the courage and heroism of players involved at every level of the game.”

Previous story: Junior Seau Family Sues the NFL for Wrongful Death Over Brain Injuries

The complaint is attached to this story.

A jury trial was demanded and the case was assigned to Superior Court Judge Randa Trapp, who has been the subject of anonymous attacks on her competence.

Attorneys for Seau’s four children, a guardian and ex-wife are led by Steven Strauss of San Diego, who defended Seau in a 2006 case brought by two women who alleged that an “obviously intoxicated” Seau ruined their clothing by throwing two large glasses of red liquid at them at a downtown San Diego bar.

“The suit seeks damages of at least $25,000 for each woman,” according to a Washington Post report in 2007. It also states Seau used ‘female-specific profanities’ to describe the women’s bodies.”

The latest suit said the NFL covered up extensive evidence of the game’s dangers to protect its cash flow.

“Annually, the NFL redistributes approximately $4 billion in radio, television, and 18 digital earnings to the teams or approximately $125 million per team,” the suit said. “Those revenue numbers have increased since 2009.”

NFL Films used players, including Seau, to “spread the fraudulent message that brutal violence is a necessary part of the sport. In 1993’s NFL Rocks, Junior Seau offered his opinion on the measure of a punishing hit: ‘If I can feel some dizziness, I know that guy is feeling double [that],’” said the suit, adding.

In a segment of the same film, former Houston Oilers receiver Ernest Givens is quoted as saying: ‘I get knocked out a lot, I get concussions, I get broken noses, that is part of being a receiver, that’s what separates you from being a typical receiver than a great receiver.

Dallas Cowboys receiver Michael Irvin recites a similar unawareness of the risks of concussions: “Before the game, I go to the [defensive backs] and tell them, `Hey, you know I’ll trade a concussion for a reception!’

In a study of NFL retirees, 11.1 percent of all respondents reported having a diagnosis of clinical depression, the suit says.

From 1994 until 2010, the NFL conducted head injury research through its Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Committee and “openly disputed that any short-term or long-term harmful effects arose from football-related sub-concussive and concussive injuries,” the suit says.

The NFL disseminated what the suit called its  “own falsified research” to support its position.

In 2010, the NFL renamed the MTBI Committee the Head, Neck and Spine Medical Committee. And in October 2011, the suit said, “Dr. Mitchel Berger of the NFL's new Head, Neck, and Spine Medical Committee announced that a new study was in the planning process. He admitted that the MTBI Committee's previous long-range study was useless because ‘[t]here was no science in that.’”

In its case against helmet-maker Riddell, the suit says: “Despite years of science and medicine linking the risk of long term brain injury from repeat concussions, it was not until the release of the Revolution Helmet wherein a notification reminding players to ‘sit out’ if they suffer a concussion was placed on the Revolution helmet.”

The suit listed some of the “extensive injuries” in Seau’s NFL career, including a chronic torn rotator cuff, shattered bones in his forearm, chronic ankle, knee, shoulder, toe injuries, back pain and “severe bruising all over his body on a regular basis.”

“Yet he rarely missed games for these injuries or even complained about pain or injuries,” the suit says. “Instead, he received injections for pain and inflammation to play through his ever-present injuries.

He also suffered “innumerable blows directly to his head” and several times was hit so hard that he suffered facial lacerations, the suit said.

“On numerous occasions, Seau left the field because he was dazed. He would sit on the sidelines until he regained his bearings and he would then return to the game,” the suit noted.

The suit slammed what it called the “despicable conduct of the NFL,” which was “fraudulent, malicious, and oppressive and was done with the intent to defraud team coaches past and present NFL players and the general public.”

Richard Cannon January 26, 2013 at 03:59 PM
If the Seau family fails to shake down the NFL to their financial satisfaction, maybe they'll sue each and every player that ever laid a finger on their unfortunately deceased cashcow.
"Da Moose" January 27, 2013 at 12:46 AM
Nobody force him to put his head in a helmet,,, like he force me to jump out of the way of his SUV,,, I WAS AWAKE WHEN I DROVE OFF THE CLIFF,,,
Frank H. Robles January 27, 2013 at 04:44 AM
Will the "Family of Jr Seau be there at Canton in 2015 when he gets inducted to the Hall of Fame...? They were there for his Charger induction . Good point about USC and Oceanside High being on the "List" to sue, maybe Popwarner also, or Mom or Dad who drove him to football pactice...!!!
"Da Moose" January 28, 2013 at 05:27 AM
it'a all about the lawyer's fighting about 1 word ,no matter what the truth is ,it's about one word ,and the win ,who's idea was the lawsuit ,A LAWYER'S IDEA
Jane Tanaka MD January 28, 2013 at 05:44 AM
9:43 pm on Sunday, January 27, 2013 Prior to the 2012 Football Season, the American Academy of Neurology published, in the journal Neurology, a study of 3500 professional football players, and found that professional football players are 4 times as likely to develop ALS ( Lou Gehrig's disease), and also had higher risk of developing Parkinson's Disease and Alzheimers Disease, compared to the general public. Attorneys did not make this up. Its important that parents know this prior to signing up their kids for football.. yes, it can happen even in middle school or high school or college... Its not a laughing matter. If you are a parent who wants your kid to be in football, consider making sure they will be the quarterback or kicker... unless the game changes to reduce repetitive head injuries. Respectfully, Jane Tanaka MD.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »